First-time

938 stories.

Sex Ed Homework

by Tail Spinner ([email protected])

First-time Teen Medium M ⚠︎ underage

anal breeding fingering

curious intense

The Taking of Innocence: Lady in Red

by Thall ([email protected])

First-time Age-gap Medium MF ⚠︎ underage

anal dominant oral

passionate rough

First-time Taboo Medium F

breeding dubcon oral

discovery educational

Becky the Farmer's Daughter - 4

by Obmuj (address withheld by request)

First-time Teen-romance Short MM ⚠︎ underage

first-time oral vaginal

emotional naive

Jamie's Rec-room

by Matchhead (address withheld by request)

First-time Underage Medium F ⚠︎ underage

creampie fingering oral

naive passionate

Fun & Games - Redux

by Gungadick ([email protected])

First-time Lesbian Long Ff ⚠︎ underage

dildo fingering oral

Midnight Visitor

by Raiderboy ([email protected])

First-time Teen Short MF ⚠︎ underage

excited romantic

Light It Up: Sabrina Learns to Fuck

by DakotaMidnight ([email protected])

First-time School-romance Short F

creampie first-time oral

erotic innocent

by Master Vankor ([email protected])

First-time School-romance Short MF ⚠︎ underage

ass fingering oral

Mitzi's Seduction

by Paula (Address withheld by request)

First-time Seduction Short MF

passionate seductive

by Raiderboy ([email protected])

First-time Teen Medium MfMm ⚠︎ underage

oral public sweat

erotic romantic

by Pan The Piper ([email protected])

First-time Teen Medium M ⚠︎ underage

bareback fingering large-cock

erotic romantic

by Raiderboy ([email protected])

First-time Teen Medium M

blowjob condom oral

erotic first-time

Cindy Cinema Slut - The First Time

by LaffWithMe ([email protected])

First-time Voyeurism Medium F ⚠︎ underage

cunnilingus exhibitionism fingering

descriptive erotic

by Pleasure Boy 1 ([email protected])

First-time Taboo-step Medium MF ⚠︎ underage

oral penetration virginity

emotional romantic

Midnight Visitor

by Raiderboy ([email protected])

First-time Teen Short MF ⚠︎ underage

fingering first-time kissing

excited passionate

From Boyhood to Manhood

by Raiderboy ([email protected])

First-time Teen Short M ⚠︎ underage

creampie oral penetration

explicit passionate

The Candy Store

by Ann Douglas ([email protected])

First-time Age-gap Medium MF

creampie cunnilingus massage

educational nostalgic

by Drauma Astridsgeta ([email protected])

First-time Teen-romance Medium MF

kissing oral public

Cash or Charge?

by Sera ([email protected])

First-time Femdom Short Ff ⚠︎ underage

exhibitionism fingering masturbation

erotic intimate